The Devaluation of Music – Thoughts in Response

A few months ago, I read this article about the devaluation of music (Peter Hollens shared it on his Facebook page). It proved to be an interesting read and provoked a lot of discussion between artists and consumers. Here I will share the main points author Craig Havighurst shares in this article and my own perspective on what he has to say. I’d love to hear your thoughts!

POINT 1: THE DEATH OF CONTEXT. Instead of liner notes, credits, and other context for the creation of the music, songs today are reduced to only Artist Name, Song Title, Album, and Album Art.

My thoughts: This is both good and bad. On the positive side, this has enabled music consumers to gather tons of music into one small item like an iPhone and be able to listen to anything they want to without having to carry around multiple music playing devices, multiple CDs, etc. You can have easy access to any music you want, which allows you to consume more altogether. But from my perspective as an artist, this means that unless my listeners know me personally, they will know nothing about my music except my name, the title of the song, the title of the album, and the image I’ve chosen for the song. Lyrics may convey a message, but without knowing what the songwriter was inspired by, the intended message is lost. As for instrumental music? It’s all the more meaningful when you know what inspired it, what the artist was thinking, how they felt, and what led to the creation of the music you are listening to. I create mostly instrumental music, and I want people to know these things about my music because context makes it more alive, powerful, and meaningful. 

POINT 2: COMMERCIAL RADIO. Radio playlists now repeat a handful of singles over and over, with very little variety. Our listening has become passive and most listeners are exposed only to overproduced hit numbers.

My thoughts: 100% agree. Today’s radio stations are no longer a place to hear new music (unless it’s a new song by a Top 10 artist). They’re not a place to hear music that has a lot of variety or interesting musicality, either. Very often radio songs have incredibly repetitive melodies and simple chord progressions (as humorously demonstrated by Axis of Awesome in the video below…warning: brief strong language around min 5:20).

POINT 3: THE MEDIA. Rather than continuing to expose the public to artists across all types of music, mainstream media is now almost exclusively pop. Media completely ignores other genres and promotes only already-known popular artists.

My thoughts: I agree for the most part. The exception is film scores, which have been known to transcend this and bring beautiful music to listeners’ ears (though listeners rarely appreciate this kind of music for what it is). Most listeners consume music from the radio or television shows only, which is almost exclusively one-note pop. Movies today no longer include musical numbers or extended dance scenes; film music is primarily used as an instrumental soundtrack. The key problem here is the type of media we consume. Gone are the days when people cared to attend plays, musicals, operas, and concerts of all varieties to enrich their lives. Now, because increasingly fewer people care about these things, the opera singers, theatre actors, orchestra pit members, composers, orchestrators, etc. are paid less and less for their life work of sharing such beauty and talent with the world. If anyone has a solution for this, please share it.

POINT 4: CONFLATION. Music is no longer just music; it has to be background music to a TV show or podcast or game. Music is no longer appreciated as something unto itself but rather as something to enhance something else.

My thoughts: This does not mean that music cannot be enjoyed along with other things, and in fact, this dual experience can enhance your appreciation of both the music and its accompanying feature. However, fewer and fewer listeners are even able to enjoy music on its own. Many will “get bored” and walk away. Why did music lose value as something unto itself? Music has the power to capture emotion, imagery, and all kinds of things without needing anything else. When was the last time you stopped what you were doing to listen to a piece of music and let it fill you? Even Looney Tunes (which is still awesome) and Little Einstein, while well-intentioned, miss this point. Just stop what you’re doing, close your eyes, and listen…your soul will be lifted, your mind will be expanded, and you will be enriched.

POINT 5: ANTI-INTELLECTUALISM. Music is valued as something with only emotional value, not intellectual value. Music is used as a tool to trigger an emotional response rather than to enrich the mind and enlighten the individual.

My thoughts: I feel that music has incredible value as an emotional tool. Music without emotion is not music at all. However, we have gone too far the other direction and have now begun to create and consume music that has little else to offer besides emotional appeal. The notion that “we only need to feel the music” robs us of the ability to appreciate music and its importance to society. Music can convey messages, understanding, intelligence, communication, creativity, and more. Not every piece of music has to be deep, layered, thought-provoking, or intellectual. Some people want to enjoy their catchy tunes and need nothing else. But if that is all that music has become, the world is worse off for it.

POINT 6: MOVIES & GAMES. Film and gaming music has led to the development of cliché musical themes where “heroism” has one sound, “romance” has another, and “grief” has another.

My thoughts: While there are repetitive motifs that are abused in music today, this idea actually devalues all that contemporary film and game composers contribute — which is so much more than the majority of mainstream pop music. I grew up surrounded by classical music and was heavily involved in studying classical piano and voice, and there is so much music in film scores and video games that I find incredibly complex, exciting, and amazing. I have found many video game scores in particular to be moving, interesting, exciting, intellectual, and uniquely complex.

young musicianPOINT 7: MUSIC IN SCHOOLS. Music is continually cut from school curricula. Attempts at curtailing this are about how music makes kids smarter, and while this is true, it also misses the mark that music makes kids more musical. Music education fosters a better musical ear and a greater interest in music.

My thoughts: I’m a music teacher AND creator, and of course I want music in the schools. Tons of academic research has proven the academic benefits of music, which is why it’s the ammunition we music advocates use. But there are other benefits, too. For my Master’s Thesis in Sociology I wanted to study this very concept, but there wasn’t sufficient national data. I ended up proving that music and other extracurricular activities increase academic self-efficacy (not only your grades but how you feel about school, your academic ambitions, how confident you are about your education, how hard you’ll work on your schoolwork, etc.). But this is still related to academia, and there is so much more that music can do for you! In studying music you learn performance skills, discipline, focus, emotional skills, creativity, problem solving skills…but above all, you become more musical. Studying persuasive writing makes you better at persuasive writing, and you learn how to recognize a good or bad argument when you see it. In the same way, studying music makes you better at music, and you learn how to recognize good or bad music when you hear it.

Other Thoughts

Users have become entitled, and Music has lost value: People feel no guilt in pirating music and thinking that they’re entitled to have any music they want. They will only pay for it if they like it enough, and many will never pay anything at all. Most music and art are no longer considered valuable for pay. Now, the only art form that yields a significant profit is film. People will pay $15 to see a film once in a movie theater but refuse to pay $1 for a song or $10 for an album they could keep forever and listen to over and over and over. It’s SO incredibly difficult to share quality music with the world today because no one wants to pay for music.

harp playerArtists get little support: Why do people think that only certain talents or skills are valuable today? The effects of music are so profound and all-encompassing. Those of us who create it know this. Those of us who consume it wisely will know it, too. Someone who dedicates their life to something they love, when that something has such great potential to influence others for good, should have the ability to make a living with it. I believe that we should value each other’s strengths and talents and be willing to pay for those things that make our lives better (like music). It is sad that people who want to study music or arts will generate massive student loan debt with no way to pay it off after school because there simply isn’t societal support for musicians and artists. If you can’t find another kind of job, you can perform or teach, but such income is often sporadic. You can only do music if you love it because it’s never a stable income like many other professions, so at least with no income you can have solace in knowing that you love what you do. Patreon is a fantastic new platform that allows “patrons” to support (i.e. pay) the artists they love, but it is only one small change when many are needed. 

Artists have to work with what they have: Music creators have to work within these demands in order to even hope for any benefit. Music creators learn quickly that only cover songs will get them attention, and those covers have to be absolutely amazing to get anyone interested enough to check out their original works. The desire for financial compensation or income does not prevent musicians from creating original works, and of course music creation has to reflect your passion and individuality, otherwise it won’t be of value to anyone. But you can’t pay bills with originality anymore. You can’t make a real living in today’s music culture unless you “make it big”. I’m fortunate to have the ability and skills to teach, but others are not so fortunate. I am striving to work within this ever-changing world, continuing to do what I love and bring others to truly enjoy and appreciate music. I appreciate all the support I receive from friends, family, students, and peers!

I will end with what Peter Hollens said on the Facebook conversation trail about this article: “The MORE people we have doing what they love for a living and creating, and inspiring and sharing their love with the world… the better. Art and music is the one thing that really brings us ALL together…Makes us act more human.” Amen!

Bri

From toddler tinkering at the keys to university music student and beyond, Brianne's whole life has revolved around music lessons, competitions, performances, and more. Now she is professionally involved in teaching, composing, orchestrating, and performing in a variety of contexts. Bri's desire is to help individuals of all ages come to enjoy the beautiful and fun nature of creating music through developing their musical talents.

Leave a Reply

Close Menu
×